Sabrina Carpenter broke the internet with an unexpected “arrest” guest and it’s not who fans expected.

The Please Please Please chart-topper’s latest pre-Juno moment didn’t go as Swifties expected.

Taylor Swift fans were convinced that the 14-time Grammy winner would be the next to be “arrested”, especially since the show took place on her hometown turf.

However, the surprise guest was none other than Nicole Kidman, who also resided in the capital of Tennessee, leaving concertgoers both shocked and delighted.

On Tuesday, November 4, at Nashville’s Bridgestone Arena the crowd erupted the moment familiar red and blue sirens echoed through the venue.

As the spotlight panned over the audience, Kidman was spotted standing in the crowd, rocking a red shirt paired with denim. 

The Babygirl star played it coy as she continued to converse with the Esprsso hitmaker on stage.

Fans reaction on Nicole Kidman’s arrest at Short n Sweet tour:

Fans couldn’t get enough of the iconic crossover, especially when the former Disney star poked fun at AMC’s viral cinema ad starring the Oscar winner joking about how “we come to this place for magic.” The reference, along with nods to Kidman’s Babygirl sent fans into a frenzy.

One admirer gushed, “Not Sabrina turning her concert into a cinematic universe.”

Another added on X (formerly Twitter), “That sounds like an absolutely iconic and hilarious moment!”

“Guilty of serving 1st degree pop excellence,” a third user said.

A fourth raved, “I guess you could say their chemistry was practically magic,” referencing Kidman’s cult classic Practical Magic.

Another remarked, “epic crossover event,” and “iconic.”

Will Taylor Swift Join Sabrina Carpenter on Stage?

For weeks, fans have been speculating about a possible Carpenter x Swift reunion during the Short n’ Sweet Tour.

Given the Cruel Summer’s songstress history of surprising audiences, especially in her hometown, Swifties were convinced this Nashville show would be the moment.

However, Travis Kelce’s fiancee didn’t make an appearance that night but hope isn’t lost. 

Carpenter, 26, has one more Nashville show, and fans are holding onto the possibility that Taylor, 35, might make a surprise cameo during the second night.